A Brief Summary of the Presentation by Kathy Bailey, Sierra Club California
Jackson State Forest EIR scoping session in Ft. Bragg, February 27, 2004


Compared to other regions in the state, there is little public forestland in the redwood region between San Francisco Bay and Humboldt County.  Jackson Forest is the only opportunity to protect and restore the region’s depleted biological heritage and provide forest-based recreation for the public. 

Jackson is also the only large public redwood forest available to practice silviculture that is not driven by debt service, mill utilization concerns, or the need to demonstrate increasing profits to stockholders on a quarterly basis.  The Citizens Advisory Committee (CAC) appointed by former CDF Director Wilson recognized this when they sent a letter to Director Wilson asking that Jackson be managed according to the principles of good silviculture rather than based on an externally driven need to make money.   

Jackson Demonstration State Forest (JDSF) is bounded north and south by two large industrial timberland owners, Hawthorne Timber LLC (Hawthorne) toward the west, and Mendocino Redwood Company (MRC) toward the east.  These ownerships extend far to the north and south.  Both are relatively new owners, being successors to Georgia-Pacific (now Hawthorne) and Louisiana Pacific (now MRC).  G-P and LP depleted their lands, culminating in the 1990s with the virtual elimination of older second growth redwoods (stands exceeding 40 years of age in a region where trees will live to be 2000 years old).  The surrounding industrial lands have only 25% of the timber volume that Jackson Forest does.       

During this period, the California Department of Forestry (CDF) approved thousands of Timber Harvest Plans and concluded that each individually and cumulatively resulted in no significant adverse impact to the environment.  Yet during this same period, ever increasing numbers of species were listed as threatened or endangered by both the state and federal governments and most of the streams in the area were listed as impaired under Section 303d of the Clean Water Act including both the Big River and the Noyo River, major watersheds in Jackson.  Each of these listings cited poor California Forest Practice Rules and logging as either primary or significant factors in the listing.  This is the regional setting around Jackson Forest.  (Maps were provided illustrating these statements.)   

Two 1990 photos taken by Nicholas Wilson show about 20 square miles of clearcuts in the Pudding Creek and Noyo watersheds, directly north of Jackson. The photos date from the time Mendocino County tried to get the Board of Forestry to approve local rules that had been developed in a long, arduous, and democratic fashion.  The Board of Forestry turned down the rules requested by our Board of Supervisors saying that the new Sustained Yield Plan (SYP) process would take care of our problems.  To date, no SYP has been approved in Mendocino County and none are pending.   

Whatever you think of the forest management in the photo, it must be acknowledged that this watershed will not be old forest anytime soon, if ever.  It is unfortunately quite typical of the region’s industrial timberland holdings.  

Another set of photos by Nicholas Wilson show an old growth redwood grove liquidated by GP in 1975, one of the last in the County.  It was located on the Little North Fork Big River, adjacent to Jackson.  After the tree was cut, it was measured at 17-foot diameter and the ring count revealed it to have been 1,540 years old.  If it’s green, those who don’t know better tend to think all is well.  But look at what we have lost!   

The ecosystem and the original balance of its plants and animals great and small have all been massively diminished in this region.  Both the people who live here and those who might come to spend some time have no option but to turn to Jackson Forest.  We ask the Board of Forestry to rearrange priorities at Jackson, resolve the longstanding conflict, and move management of the forest into a new and productive era.